How secret nighttime phone use is damaging the minds of children as young as 7
7 mins read

How secret nighttime phone use is damaging the minds of children as young as 7

child in bed with phonechild in bed with phone

(Photo by TungArt7 from Pixabay)

ADELAIDE, Australia — The monsters keeping our kids up at night aren’t cartoon characters—they’re made of pixels and social media likes. A comprehensive study reveals a worrying trend: late-night phone use is turning bedtime into a battleground for sleep and mental health. Research from Australia reveals a worrying link between late-night texting, cyberbullying, and psychological distress in children as young as seven.

The childhood rite of passage of staying up past bedtime has taken a dark turn in the digital age, researchers say. The study, published in the journal Teenagersanalyzed data from more than 53,000 Australian children aged seven to 19. For many children, “lights out” is just the beginning of their nighttime online activities — and the consequences go beyond feeling sleepy the next day.

Data collection took place between March and December 2019, using a questionnaire examining various aspects of resilience and well-being. The survey included demographic items, risk and protective behavior items, and optional risk behavior items.

To understand how kids were feeling, researchers used a special set of questions called the PHQ-4. It asked kids whether they felt nervous, worried, sad, or uninterested. Their answers ranged from “Never” to “Almost every day.”

Other questions included how often children used their phones at night, how well they slept, or whether they had been bullied online. For example, they asked whether children slept eight hours most nights and how many times they sent messages on their phones late at night. They also asked whether children had been bullied at school recently.

One of the most striking findings was that around a third of primary school children (aged 7–11) and over 60% of secondary school children (aged 12–19) reported using their phones at night at least once a week. This nighttime phone use was associated with shorter sleep duration and increased psychological distress across all age groups.

But it’s not just about losing sleep. The study also found that kids who experienced cyberbullying were more likely to use their phones at night and report sleep and psychological problems. About 15% of kids surveyed had experienced cyberbullying in the previous school term, with rates peaking in early adolescence.

“Adolescents are at greater risk for socio-emotional disorders because they are at a stage of development where they are less prepared cognitively, behaviorally, and neurobiologically,” study co-author Dr. Stephanie Centofanti, a researcher at the University of South Australia, said in a statement.

Teenage girl in bed looking at smartphone at nightTeenage girl in bed looking at smartphone at night
One in three primary school children (7-11 years old) and over 60% of secondary school students (12-19 years old) admitted to using their phone at night at least once a week. (© De Visu – stock.adobe.com)

Centofanti and her team used a clever approach to investigate the relationship between nighttime phone use, cyberbullying, sleep, and psychological distress. They tested whether nighttime phone use might exacerbate the negative effects of cyberbullying on sleep and mental health.

Interestingly, the results showed some unexpected patterns. For boys, especially those in high school, using their phones at night did indeed worsen the psychological distress associated with cyberbullying. But the effect was stronger for boys who had not experienced cyberbullying. The researchers suggest that this may be due to a “ceiling effect”—children who had been cyberbullied already reported such high levels of stress that there wasn’t much room for it to increase any further.

In terms of sleep, nighttime phone use was found to exacerbate the negative impact of cyberbullying on sleep quality for both boys and girls across all age groups. Again, this effect was surprisingly stronger for children who had not experienced cyberbullying.

The study’s findings aren’t as simple as saying “phones are bad.” Instead, the research points to the need for better approaches to managing children’s digital device use, especially at night.

For parents, educators, and health care providers, this study reinforces the importance of addressing nighttime phone use as part of overall strategies to improve children’s sleep and mental health. This could include establishing household rules around screen time after bed, educating kids about the importance of sleep, and being alert for signs of cyberbullying.

“It is clear that parents need to pay more attention to managing smartphone use at night, especially if their children are more susceptible to cyberbullying, and make sure their children get enough sleep,” says Dr Centofanti.

As our world becomes increasingly digital, understanding how technology impacts our children’s well-being is more important than ever. This study provides valuable insights that can help shape healthier digital habits for the next generation.

Article Summary

Methodology

The researchers used data from a large study of Australian students. The study asked questions about night-time phone use, sleep habits, experiences with cyberbullying, and psychological distress. To measure psychological distress, they used a short, four-item questionnaire called the Patient Health Questionnaire-4 (PHQ-4). The researchers then used statistical techniques to analyze how these different factors related to each other, looking at differences between age groups and genders.

Key Results

The study found that nighttime phone use and cyberbullying were independently associated with shorter sleep duration and higher levels of psychological distress. When they looked at the interactions of these factors, they found that nighttime phone use exacerbated the negative effects of cyberbullying on sleep for all children.

In the case of psychological stress, this worsening effect was seen mainly in boys, especially in secondary school. Interestingly, the negative effects of nighttime phone use were often stronger in children who had not experienced cyberbullying, probably because those who had been cyberbullied already reported very high levels of stress and poor sleep.

Limitations of the study

The study relied on self-reported data, which can be subject to error. It also used single-item measures for some factors, such as sleep and cyberbullying, which may not capture the full complexity of these issues. The cross-sectional nature of the study means that causal relationships cannot be proven. In addition, the study did not collect information about the specific timing or content of phone use at night, or whether cyberbullying occurred at night.

Discussion and conclusions

The researchers emphasize the importance of managing digital device use at night as a strategy to manage susceptibility to cyberbullying and improve sleep health. They suggest that future studies should look more closely at the timing of cyberbullying and compare the effects of cyberbullying during the day and at night. The study also emphasizes the need for an age- and gender-specific approach to addressing these issues, as patterns differed across groups.

Financing and Disclosure

The study did not receive any external funding. However, it is worth noting that some of the researchers are affiliated with Resilient Youth Australia, the organization that provided the data for the study. This affiliation is disclosed in the article to provide transparency about potential conflicts of interest.